
Discussions about the tragedy of the early 1930s in Kazakhstani society have long gone beyond the boundaries of academic debates and archival research. The massive social and economic collapse that entered history under the name Asharshylyk affected practically every family, reshaping the demographic map of Eurasia and destroying the traditional nomadic way of life that had developed over centuries.

Poverty at the market. Pavlodar Region, 1920s–1930s. Photo: Central State Archive of Film, Photo Documents and Sound Recordings of the Republic of Kazakhstan, archival No. 5-3448.
According to the renowned American historian Sarah Cameron, in her fundamental work The Hungry Steppe: Famine, Violence, and the Making of Soviet Kazakhstan, published by Cornell University Press, more than 1.5 million people died from famine and associated epidemics between 1930 and 1933. This amounted to approximately one-quarter of the population of the Kazakh Soviet Socialist Republic, making this humanitarian catastrophe one of the most devastating in world history during the first half of the twentieth century in terms of the percentage of the total population lost.
The “Little October” Policy and the Destruction of the Steppe Way of Life

Filipp Goloshchekin delivering a report at the Sixth All-Kazakh Congress of Soviets. Kazakhstan, 1927.
Attempts to understand the causes of this disaster invariably lead researchers to the policies of forced collectivization and compulsory sedentarization carried out under the regional leadership headed by Filipp Goloshchekin. The concept of “Little October,” proclaimed in Kazakhstan, envisaged a radical restructuring of the aul, the elimination of traditional institutions of self-government, and the expropriation of livestock from large property owners.

Preparations for military conscription at the military commissariat. Pavlodar, 1929. Photo: Central State Archive of Film, Photo Documents and Sound Recordings of the Republic of Kazakhstan, archival No. 5-3473.
As Sarah Cameron emphasizes, the Soviet leadership viewed the destruction of the nomadic economy not merely as an economic measure but as a crucial ideological instrument for subordinating autonomous peripheral regions to a rigid central authority, despite repeated warnings from local specialists about the catastrophic consequences.
-1400x933.jpg?2026-11-11T17:12:03.362Z)
Kazakh aul. 1928. Photo: Central State Archive of Film, Photo Documents and Sound Recordings of the Republic of Kazakhstan, archival No. 2-39320.
The scale of the destruction of the region’s livestock economy was unprecedented. According to research by Kazakhstani historian Zhanna Saktaganova on socioeconomic processes in Central Kazakhstan, the numbers of cattle and small livestock in the republic declined by 80–90 percent.

During migration. Pavlodar Region, 1930s. Photo: Central State Archive of Film, Photo Documents and Sound Recordings of the Republic of Kazakhstan, archival No. 5-3515.
For Kazakh nomads, livestock was not simply property but a complex ecosystem that provided nutritious food, clothing, transportation, and the very means of survival in the harsh climatic conditions of the steppe. The compulsory seizure of animals, accompanied by the campaign of asyra silteu (excesses committed by local authorities), deprived the population of its means of subsistence.

A young Kazakh man sitting at the entrance to the Aulie-Tas Cave near Bayanaul. Pavlodar Region, 1928. Photo: Central State Archive of Film, Photo Documents and Sound Recordings of the Republic of Kazakhstan, archival No. 5-3466.
In his work Famine in the Steppe: The Collectivization of Agriculture and the 1930-33 Disaster, published in academic studies on Soviet history, Italian researcher Niccolò Pianciola traces in detail the mechanism through which traditional trade and economic connections between steppe regions and settled centers were destroyed. Pianciola notes that absurd and inherently impossible grain procurement targets were imposed on a region historically unsuited to large-scale grain agriculture.

Kazakh woman. Pavlodar Region, 1920s–1930s. Photo: Central State Archive of Film, Photo Documents and Sound Recordings of the Republic of Kazakhstan, archival No. 5-3357.
As a result, under the pretext of fulfilling procurement plans, the last remaining supplies of edible grain and surviving livestock were confiscated from famine-stricken auls. Any attempts by peasants and nomads to migrate in search of food to neighboring Russian regions, China, or Central Asia were strictly suppressed through restrictive measures and the closure of administrative borders.
Demographic Collapse and the Exodus Beyond the Steppe

People leaving their homes and migrating in an attempt to survive the famine. Kazakhstan, 1930s.
The demographic impact of Asharshylyk was not limited to deaths directly caused by starvation and diseases such as typhus and malaria. The catastrophe triggered a mass exodus of people beyond the borders of the Soviet republic. Seeking to escape almost certain death, more than one million people fled to Xinjiang (China), Mongolia, Afghanistan, and Iran. A significant proportion of these people remained abroad, forming large Kazakh diasporas outside their homeland.

Starving people in an overcrowded room. Kazakhstan, 1930–1933.
A comparative analysis of the Soviet population censuses of 1926 and 1939 conducted by demographers reveals a colossal decline: ethnic Kazakhs lost their status as the absolute majority in their own homeland. While Kazakhs accounted for approximately 58–60 percent of the region’s population in 1926, by the end of the 1930s their share had fallen to around 38 percent as a result of the famine, subsequent political repression, and the massive influx of settlers during industrialization and the development of new territories.
Figures and Models of Development Without the Catastrophe

Children left without parental care, one of the consequences of Asharshylyk in Kazakhstan. 1930s.
A natural question arises, one that historians, commentators, and demographers regularly discuss: what would Kazakhstan look like today if this humanitarian catastrophe had never occurred? In seeking to answer this question, researchers rely on counterfactual analysis, mathematical modeling, and data on natural population growth in the early twentieth century.

A living girl discovered among rags in a haystack. According to the archival caption, the child had been abducted with the intention of being used as food. Tokmak, during the famine of the 1930s. Photo: archival photograph.
The prominent Kazakhstani demographer Makash Tatimov repeatedly emphasized in his many years of research the exceptional reproductive potential of traditional Kazakh families. In the early 1930s, the fertility rate in Kazakh auls was approximately 7–9 children per woman of reproductive age, alongside a high, although seasonally fluctuating, level of adaptation to steppe conditions.

Famine in the Kazakh steppe (Asharshylyk). Photo: State Archive of South Kazakhstan Region.
If standard demographic projections of exponential and logistic growth are applied, taking into account the decline in infant mortality during subsequent medical modernization, calculations indicate that by the beginning of the twenty-first century the number of ethnic Kazakhs living within their historical areas of settlement in Central Asia alone should have reached 28–35 million people. On a global scale, including diasporas in China, Mongolia, and other countries, this figure would inevitably have reached 45–55 million people.

Graves of infants near the Moyandy recreation area. Pavlodar Region, 1931. Photo: Central State Archive of Film, Photo Documents and Sound Recordings of the Republic of Kazakhstan, archival No. 5-4383.
For comparison, the actual number of Kazakhs worldwide, according to censuses conducted in the early 2020s, barely exceeds 16–18 million. Thus, the demographic deficit caused exclusively by the events of 1930–1933 and their long-term consequences amounts to the colossal figure of 30–35 million people who were never born.
Evolutionary Economic Modernization Instead of Total Destruction

Preparing baursaks. Pavlodar Region, 1920s. Photo: Central State Archive of Film, Photo Documents and Sound Recordings of the Republic of Kazakhstan, archival No. 5-3511.
Without the forced destruction of the traditional pastoral economy, the transition of Kazakh households toward settled life and modern industrial forms of labor would have taken place naturally and gradually. In the early 1920s, livestock numbers in the Kazakh Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic were growing steadily and exceeded 40–42 million animals of all types (equivalent to more than 6.5–7 million standardized cattle units). With gradual cooperative organization and the progressive introduction of commodity-money relations, this figure could have increased to 70–80 million animals by 1940.

Livestock with offspring. Pavlodar Region, 1920s–1930s. Photo: Central State Archive of Film, Photo Documents and Sound Recordings of the Republic of Kazakhstan, archival No. 5-3497.
Agricultural science could have introduced selective breeding methods, advanced processing of livestock products, and pasture improvement without the need to completely destroy the material foundation of an entire people. Preserving millions of human lives and preventing forced emigration would have made it possible to create an exceptionally powerful domestic labor market and human capital focused on maintaining the ecological balance of steppe landscapes, rather than exhausting the soil through extensive agricultural campaigns such as the subsequent Virgin Lands campaign.
The Ethnopolitical and Linguistic Landscape of an Alternative Kazakhstan

Winter settlement. Pavlodar Region, 1933. Photo: Central State Archive of Film, Photo Documents and Sound Recordings of the Republic of Kazakhstan, archival No. 5-3571.
Furthermore, the ethnopolitical and cultural landscape of modern Kazakhstan would have been fundamentally different. Preserving the absolute demographic majority of the indigenous population within its historical territory would have altered the trajectory of urbanization during the second half of the twentieth century.

Carrying water. Pavlodar Region, 1920s–1930s. Photo: Central State Archive of Film, Photo Documents and Sound Recordings of the Republic of Kazakhstan, archival No. 5-3498.
While in reality the share of Kazakhs in their own republic fell to a historic low of 30 percent in 1959, with natural population growth preserved and without the migration shock, Kazakhs would have accounted for at least 75–80 percent of the population of the Ukrainian SSR/Kazakh SSR by the middle of the century.

A family moving to the city because of the famine. Pavlodar Region, 1930s. Photo: Central State Archive of Film, Photo Documents and Sound Recordings of the Republic of Kazakhstan, archival No. 5-3620.
The linguistic environment, public education system, and development of national literature, science, and the arts would have evolved under conditions of uninterrupted cultural continuity, without the catastrophic rupture between generations. The republic would have entered the period of gaining state independence in 1991 with an entirely different level of institutional and social resilience, sparing future generations the need to spend decades overcoming the consequences of a profound demographic and psychological crisis.
Main photo: A girl collecting dried animal dung for fuel. Pavlodar Region, 1920s–1930s. Photo: Central State Archive of Film, Photo Documents and Sound Recordings of the Republic of Kazakhstan, archival No. 5-4355.
Archival photographs have been processed using artificial intelligence technologies to improve image quality.

The history of the kurultai, from steppe councils to Kazakhstan’s modern parliament, explained by historian Zhaksylyk Sabitov.

The scent history of the Great Steppe: from Old Turkic yıpar and musk to ätir, jūpar and contemporary perfumery in Kazakhstan.

A detailed account of the 1986 December protest in Almaty and the people whose lives were forever changed. Photo story for Shanger.kz

Село Капал в Жетысу — место Шокана Уалиханова, Фатимы Габитовой и купца Атбасарова. Фоторепортаж о том, как жители возрождают архитектурное наследие.

Witness accounts and hidden history of Kazakhstan’s 1986 December protests...Фоторепортаж Карлыгаш Нуржан для Shanger.kz ....

The Kazakh diaspora in Turkey: migration history, daily life, traditions and human stories… Фоторепортаж Карлыгаш Нуржан для Shanger.kz

A documentary account of Karlag, political repression, the Dolinka camp, and survivor testimonies. By Karlygash Nurzhan for Shanger.kz

Stories of kandas families returning to Batyr village, Mangystau Region: famine, exile, and a return to ancestral land nearly a century later.
Comments
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!