Shanger.kz

Kazakhstan invites the world to talk about the Golden Horde

Shanger.kz
Participants of the international symposium on the Golden Horde in Astana discuss the history of the Ulus of Jochi, the legacy of steppe civilization and Kazakhstan’s place in Eurasian history. Golden Horde, Ulus of Jochi, Astana, Nazarbayev University, Genghis Khan, Kazakhstan, History of Kazakhstan, Medieval History, Steppe Civilization, Shanger.kz

Disputes around the figure of Genghis Khan and his political legacy still have not subsided. This is why, on May 19–20, Kazakhstan gathered 300 delegates from more than 20 countries at Nazarbayev University to give a new scale to an open conversation about the place of the Jochid Ulus in the history of Eurasia. Shanger.kz attended the symposium to present its readers with the views of several historians on the medieval era of the Jochid Ulus, its political significance, cultural heritage, place in world history, and connection with Kazakhstan.

THE KAZAKH KHANATE IS ONE OF THE SUCCESSOR STATES OF THE JOCHID ULUS

Participants of the international symposium on the Golden Horde in Astana discuss the history of the Ulus of Jochi, the legacy of steppe civilization and Kazakhstan’s place in Eurasian history. Golden Horde, Ulus of Jochi, Astana, Nazarbayev University, Genghis Khan, Kazakhstan, History of Kazakhstan, Medieval History, Steppe Civilization, Shanger.kz

Uli Schamiloglu, Doctor of Philosophy (PhD), Professor at Nazarbayev University (Kazakhstan).

“When I am asked what tribal and political lines connect the Golden Horde with the formation of the Kazakh Khanate, I always try to begin with a reservation: this process was much more complex than a simple transfer of a state ‘from hand to hand’,” says Professor Uli Schamiloglu. “In the early thirteenth century, tribal groups were distributed among the descendants of Genghis Khan, and by the end of the Golden Horde, that is, roughly by the middle of the fourteenth century, we already see stable political combinations of tribes within various Horde formations. The Kazakh Khanate emerged as a departure from the previous political system, and the word ‘Kazakh’ itself, in this sense, points to separation, to leaving, to a different way of political existence.”

“At the same time, I quite definitely consider the Kazakh Khanate to be one of the successor states of the Jochid Ulus. There are enough reasons for this. First, the population came from that same earlier space. Second, many of the same tribal components were preserved, even if not in an identical configuration. Third, the descendants of Genghis Khan stood at the head of power, and for steppe statehood this is already sufficient to speak of continuity. Yes, the political structure changed; it was not an exact copy of the previous state. But continuity does not require literal repetition.”

KAZAKHSTAN’S SUBTLE DIPLOMACY THROUGH A SHARED VIEW OF THE GOLDEN HORDE’S LEGACY

Participants of the international symposium on the Golden Horde in Astana discuss the history of the Ulus of Jochi, the legacy of steppe civilization and Kazakhstan’s place in Eurasian history. Golden Horde, Ulus of Jochi, Astana, Nazarbayev University, Genghis Khan, Kazakhstan, History of Kazakhstan, Medieval History, Steppe Civilization, Shanger.kz

Uradyn Bulag, Professor of Social Anthropology, PhD, University of Cambridge (United Kingdom).

“When a state turns to the Jochid Ulus as one of the sources of its own historical subjectivity, this inevitably requires a rethinking of familiar schemes,” says Professor Uradyn Bulag. “This is intellectual work on a tremendous scale, and, in my view, it is only just beginning. Kazakhstan has to position itself in relation to several great worlds at once: the Russian, Turkic, Persian, Islamic, Chinese, and Mongolian worlds. Behind each of these spaces stands a vast historical memory. And if the Golden Horde is part of this broad Eurasian history, then Kazakhstan must define its own position very clearly within this complex map.”

“What is important is that Kazakhstan is doing this through an invitation to a shared conversation. In China and Mongolia, for example, debates have long been going on about who is the ‘true’ keeper of the Mongol legacy. Such disputes can easily turn into a competition for historical ownership. That is why I particularly appreciate the path I saw here, at the symposium. Kazakhstan is not saying that this legacy belongs only to it. On the contrary, it invites everyone to share this history and discuss it together. This is a wise step. Otherwise, any appeal to the Golden Horde could be perceived by neighbours as an act of historical appropriation.”

“Kazakhstan’s future, it seems to me, is largely connected with the extent to which it will be able to build relations with its neighbours through the culture of a host who knows how to receive a guest, respect him, and at the same time clearly define his own subjectivity. This requires subtle diplomacy. And in this sense, the symposium gives the impression of a mature step.”

NOMADS HAVE BEEN AND REMAIN THE MAIN LINK BETWEEN EAST AND WEST

Participants of the international symposium on the Golden Horde in Astana discuss the history of the Ulus of Jochi, the legacy of steppe civilization and Kazakhstan’s place in Eurasian history. Golden Horde, Ulus of Jochi, Astana, Nazarbayev University, Genghis Khan, Kazakhstan, History of Kazakhstan, Medieval History, Steppe Civilization, Shanger.kz

Jack Weatherford, author on the history of Genghis Khan and the Mongol Empire, Professor of Anthropology at Macalester College in Minnesota (USA, emeritus).

“For most of the human past, it was the nomads who were the main link between East and West,” says Professor Jack Weatherford. “They transmitted not only goods, but also ideas, languages, books, writing systems, medicines, technologies, and forms of knowledge. Then, about five hundred years ago, the emphasis shifted from the steppe to the sea, and all connections began to be built along maritime routes, from port to port, from country to country. Against this background, the significance of the steppe was diminished, and nomadic civilization was pushed to the periphery, as if everything important was no longer happening there.”

“But today the situation is changing again. In the technological age, the sea no longer plays the role it once did, and technologies can operate anywhere. In this sense, Astana is a very telling example. The nomadic mind has always better understood the connections between east and west, north and south; it has always worked more easily with mobile space than settled thinking did. That is why I say that the nomadic mind today is, in a certain sense, the mind of cyberspace. When a person sits down at a computer and enters the digital world, he, in a certain sense, becomes a nomad again. And in this new world, the skills of steppe civilization acquire an unexpectedly modern resonance.”

“As for Genghis Khan himself, I believe that many of his ideas were extraordinarily advanced. He believed in a single world order in which peoples should cooperate. He stood for religious freedom, for the protection of envoys, merchants, and diplomatic missions, for the safety of women, who could not be bought and sold as things. Today, almost every country in the world will say that it shares these principles. But if we look at reality, we will see that in many cases humanity still has not reached the level that was proclaimed back then. Women are still sold, diplomats are still killed, religions are persecuted, and genuine tolerance exists almost nowhere. Therefore, the legacy of Genghis Khan is a set of political ideas that still have not been fully realized.”

“Genghis Khan created an infrastructure through which envoys and merchants could move quickly, change horses, rest, and receive provisions. By the time of Ögedei’s death, a message could travel from Hungary to Mongolia in six weeks; for that era, this was an incredible speed. And there is one more point that is essential for me: Kazakhstan remains one of those spaces where the memory of nomadic life has been preserved as part of historical self-awareness. That is why Kazakhstan, in my view, is once again becoming one of the important centres of the world — of financial, educational, communication, and historical connections.”

KAZAKHSTAN HAS PRESERVED THE POLITICAL MEMORY OF THE GOLDEN HORDE

Participants of the international symposium on the Golden Horde in Astana discuss the history of the Ulus of Jochi, the legacy of steppe civilization and Kazakhstan’s place in Eurasian history. Golden Horde, Ulus of Jochi, Astana, Nazarbayev University, Genghis Khan, Kazakhstan, History of Kazakhstan, Medieval History, Steppe Civilization, Shanger.kz

Qiu Yihao, researcher at the Department of History, Fudan University (China).

“I believe that Kazakhstan can be considered one of the successful continuations of the political and civilizational line that took shape in the world of Genghis Khan and his descendants,” says researcher Qiu Yihao. “An empire is not only territory and the fact of military control. It is also the ability to preserve a political idea, to organize different peoples, to connect nomadic and settled societies, and to maintain a cultural framework even when the former centre has already weakened. After the Chinggisids lost control over a significant part of their possessions, the very idea of organizing space, governing different peoples, and connecting cultures did not disappear. This is what I call legacy. In this sense, Kazakhstan can be seen as one of the states in which this political memory and this civilizational inertia continued to live.”

Reference: On May 19, 2026, President Kassym-Jomart Tokayev stated that Kazakhstan is the direct heir of the Jochid Ulus, or the Golden Horde. According to him, the continuity of the Great Steppe is officially enshrined in the new Constitution, while the central idea of that era, “Mäñgilik El,” serves as a strategic guideline for modern Kazakhstan. The head of state said this at the international symposium “The Golden Horde as a Model of Steppe Civilization,” emphasizing the importance of deeply understanding historical heritage.

THE STUDY OF THE JOCHID ULUS MUST RELY ON PERSIAN AND ARABIC SOURCES

Participants of the international symposium on the Golden Horde in Astana discuss the history of the Ulus of Jochi, the legacy of steppe civilization and Kazakhstan’s place in Eurasian history. Golden Horde, Ulus of Jochi, Astana, Nazarbayev University, Genghis Khan, Kazakhstan, History of Kazakhstan, Medieval History, Steppe Civilization, Shanger.kz

Michael Hope, PhD, Doctor of History, Head of Asian Studies at Underwood International College, Yonsei University (South Korea).

“The perception of the Mongol conquest in different sources was very different from the outset,” says Dr Michael Hope. “Everything depends on the chronicle, the genre, and the environment in which this experience was described. In the Islamic world, the conquest was often perceived as a catastrophe, as a time of terror and punishment, almost as an apocalypse. In the Persian tradition, there are historical texts, poetry, and writings that called on Muslims to resist the Mongols. In the Russian chronicles, we are dealing with monastic and ecclesiastical writing, which is an entirely different type of narrative. Therefore, we cannot speak of a single image of the conquest: the same process was described in different ways, and these descriptions changed over time.”

“In many Arabic texts, we see the trace of an oral tradition that entered written culture through the Qipchaq milieu, and therefore one can hear local bitterness there, the memory of confrontation, and the experience of coexistence. For Western Christians, the steppe was an almost unknown world: a foreign religion, a foreign language, a foreign way of life, a foreign political system. That is precisely why it was more difficult for them to understand this world than it was for Muslims, for whom the Turkic milieu was still much closer and more comprehensible.”

“When it comes to working with sources on the Jochid Ulus, I am convinced that without Persian and Arabic material we will not understand this world in its fullness. Persian was one of the most important languages of the Mongol Empire; these sources contain a great deal of information about the genealogy of the Jochids, their relations with other branches of the Chinggisids, and diplomacy. Arabic texts are especially important also because Syria and Egypt maintained close ties with the Jochid Ulus. If we truly want to study the Jochid Ulus, we need to read Persian and Arabic materials first, and only then Russian ones. Rus’ was only part of a much broader world, while the Qipchaq steppe had its own history — rich and independent.”

WITHOUT THE GOLDEN HORDE, THERE WOULD HAVE BEEN NO MUSCOVITE STATE

Participants of the international symposium on the Golden Horde in Astana discuss the history of the Ulus of Jochi, the legacy of steppe civilization and Kazakhstan’s place in Eurasian history. Golden Horde, Ulus of Jochi, Astana, Nazarbayev University, Genghis Khan, Kazakhstan, History of Kazakhstan, Medieval History, Steppe Civilization, Shanger.kz

Maxim Shevchenko, Russian journalist, political and public figure, and publicist.

“The idea of the Horde and the so-called Mongol-Tatar yoke is an absolute myth, later shaped as a Polish-Lithuanian construct that deliberately demonized the relationship of the Russian people with their eastern neighbour,” says Maxim Leonardovich. “Then this line, in my view, was picked up by Nikolay Karamzin, who presented the Horde period as ‘three hundred years of civilizational catastrophe’ and laid the foundation for a biased, propagandistic, Masonic-European-liberal view of history, which I see as anti-Eastern, anti-Eurasian, and in many ways anti-Russian. It is fundamentally important for me to speak about this here, because the dispute over the Golden Horde is a dispute over the very construction of historical memory.”

“I also believe that without the Golden Horde there would have been no Muscovite state, no unified Russian state with its centre in Moscow. Without it, Rus’ could very well have become Catholic and been defeated by Lithuania. Relations between Moscow and the Golden Horde were politically much clearer than they are usually portrayed in simplified historiography. The Horde practically did not interfere in the internal politics of Rus’, but it gave it military strength and the geopolitical resource that allowed it to resist first Lithuanian, and then Catholic Western expansion. Therefore, I believe that this alliance, despite all its complexity, was objectively useful for Russian civilization.”

THE NAME “GOLDEN HORDE” ENTERED CIRCULATION ONLY IN RUSSIAN SOURCES OF THE FIFTEENTH CENTURY; IT IS MORE CORRECT TO CALL IT THE JOCHID ULUS

Participants of the international symposium on the Golden Horde in Astana discuss the history of the Ulus of Jochi, the legacy of steppe civilization and Kazakhstan’s place in Eurasian history. Golden Horde, Ulus of Jochi, Astana, Nazarbayev University, Genghis Khan, Kazakhstan, History of Kazakhstan, Medieval History, Steppe Civilization, Shanger.kz

Urangua Khereed Jamsran, Doctor of Historical Sciences, Mongolian State University (Mongolia).

“The Golden Horde, of course, disintegrated as a unified state, but its continuity was preserved,” says Dr Jamsrany Urangua. “The legitimacy of the Chinggisids was preserved, ulus principles were preserved, and important elements of political culture were preserved. After the disintegration, several independent states emerged, and among them were those that preserved the nomadic way of life and continued the political tradition of the steppe world. For Kazakh history, this is especially important, because Chinggisid continuity here was real: the supreme rulers were descendants of Genghis Khan, and the status of the Tore lineage remained privileged and decisive for ideas of legitimate power.”

“At the same time, I emphasize that this system did not remain unchanged. Local aristocrats gradually grew stronger, internal transformations took place, the structure of power changed, and later new forms of organization appeared, including the division into zhuzes. In other words, we are dealing with a long adaptation of the legacy to a new political reality. That is precisely why the speech by the President of Kazakhstan seemed important to me. He spoke about the fact that earlier the study of the Golden Horde was too often reduced to military and political history, to conquests and conflicts, while now it is important to study intellectual, identity-related, and ideological history, because such a turn changes the very angle of view.”

“I also consider it fundamentally important not to mix scholarly discussion with popular fantasies. I have not seen a single serious, competent scholar who would claim that Genghis Khan was Kazakh. That is unscientific. It is another matter that the rulers of the Kazakh Khanate were indeed descendants of Genghis Khan, and from this side the connection is obvious. But Genghis Khan himself was Mongol, and this must be said directly. The Golden Horde lives on today as a cultural, spiritual, and historical reality. And that is why I very much liked the fact that in Kazakhstan the correct name, the Jochid Ulus, is increasingly being restored. The name ‘Golden Horde’ appeared later; it entered circulation only in Russian sources of the fifteenth century.”

THE HISTORY OF THE GOLDEN HORDE AT TIMES RESEMBLES “GAME OF THRONES”

Participants of the international symposium on the Golden Horde in Astana discuss the history of the Ulus of Jochi, the legacy of steppe civilization and Kazakhstan’s place in Eurasian history. Golden Horde, Ulus of Jochi, Astana, Nazarbayev University, Genghis Khan, Kazakhstan, History of Kazakhstan, Medieval History, Steppe Civilization, Shanger.kz

Zhaksylyk Sabitov, PhD, geneticist, Director of the Scientific Institute for the Study of the Jochid Ulus (Kazakhstan).

“I would not call the Great Troubles the end of the Golden Horde,” says Professor Zhaksylyk Muratovich. “For me, it was first of all a political crisis that arose from a combination of several factors. One of them was dynastic: the line of Batu was cut off, including because of the actions of Berdibek, who destroyed many of his relatives. The second factor was the Black Death, the plague, which wiped out a significant part of the urban population and dealt a heavy blow to the economy, finances, and political stability. Therefore, the Great Troubles were a rehearsal for the future collapse. This is important to understand, because after it Tokhtamysh managed to reunify the Golden Horde and launch a kind of Golden Horde renaissance. Both in the era of Tokhtamysh and in the era of Edigu, we still see a powerful potential for restoration, while the final processes of disintegration unfolded later.”

Reference: The Great Troubles were a period of brutal internecine wars and political crisis in the Golden Horde, lasting from 1359 to 1380.

“When we speak about the period of the Troubles, it is indeed very convenient for storytelling: twenty-five khans in twenty years. In this sense, the history of the Golden Horde at times resembles Game of Thrones, only real. But from a scholarly point of view, what matters more is how post-Horde states gradually began to emerge from political chaos. At first, they existed as parts of a common space; then they became increasingly separate; and after dozens of generations, we already see the formation of those communities that would later become prototypes of modern peoples: Kazakhs, Tatars, Nogais, Bashkirs, and others.”

“For me, khan lines and genealogies are especially important. If we speak about the descendants of Jochi, then the central line for the Kazakh khans is the line of Tuqa-Timur, from which Urus Khan, Zhanibek, and Kerei descended. But other branches are also important: the Orda-Ejenids, the Shibanids, the descendants of Batu, the descendants of Berke. The descendants of Shiban still live among the Kazakhs. In this sense, the genealogies of khans are full-fledged documents of political continuity. When we analyze such texts as scholarly sources, we see how through them a line is constructed from Genghis Khan and Jochi to later khans, all the way to the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. For understanding Kazakh statehood, this connection is fundamental.”

WHERE THERE WERE CHINGGISIDS, THERE WAS ALWAYS ORDER

Participants of the international symposium on the Golden Horde in Astana discuss the history of the Ulus of Jochi, the legacy of steppe civilization and Kazakhstan’s place in Eurasian history. Golden Horde, Ulus of Jochi, Astana, Nazarbayev University, Genghis Khan, Kazakhstan, History of Kazakhstan, Medieval History, Steppe Civilization, Shanger.kz

Aibolat Kushkumbayev, Doctor of Historical Sciences, medievalist, Professor at L. N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University.

“And if we speak about Kazakhstan, we must remember that the Chinggisids ruled here effectively until the middle of the nineteenth century, and their political authority remained strong for a very long time,” says Professor Aibolat Kairslyamovich. “Since the time of Genghis Khan, only his direct descendants could claim supreme power. If we speak about the Golden Horde, these were the descendants of Jochi, the eldest son of Genghis Khan. Representatives of other clans and tribes could not be proclaimed khans. This was a strict dynastic principle, and it dominated the political system. The authority of the khan was the key institution, but alongside it there also existed the qurultai, an assembly of the nobility, where the most important public matters were decided. The Jochid Ulus itself was organized in a very complex way, because it included both steppe regions with nomadic populations and settled agricultural areas. Hence the dual system of administration: one logic for nomadic territories, another for settled lands, but within a single state framework.”

“The decimal system of administrative-territorial division was also very important: tens, hundreds, thousands, tumens. It was a practical mechanism for governing an enormous space, connected both with military organization and with the taxation system. Large regions, too, could be called tumens, and a certain amount of revenue was expected from them for the khan’s treasury. But the system itself did not remain unchanged. If in the thirteenth century representatives of the Chinggisids stood at the head of large uluses, then already under Özbek Khan a serious administrative reform began. Chinggisids in the regions were partially removed from administration, the role of the beklerbek was strengthened, ulus-begs were appointed, and a new system of districts was created.”

NUMISMATICS IS ONE OF THE MOST PRECISE SOURCES FOR THE HISTORY OF THE GOLDEN HORDE

Participants of the international symposium on the Golden Horde in Astana discuss the history of the Ulus of Jochi, the legacy of steppe civilization and Kazakhstan’s place in Eurasian history. Golden Horde, Ulus of Jochi, Astana, Nazarbayev University, Genghis Khan, Kazakhstan, History of Kazakhstan, Medieval History, Steppe Civilization, Shanger.kz

Pavel Petrov, Candidate of Historical Sciences, Senior Research Fellow at the A. Kh. Khalikov Institute of Archaeology of the Academy of Sciences of the Republic of Tatarstan, a well-known specialist in the numismatics of the Great Mongol Empire.

“A coin gives concrete information: the name of the issuer, the mint, the year of minting,” says numismatist Pavel Nikolaevich. “When you arrange coins in chronological order, you see who minted money in which years, where his power operated, where he disappears, and where another ruler appears. Chronicles, however, are always politicized. They were commissioned by influential people; authors often distorted facts to suit the patron, and the texts themselves have often reached us in late copies, with errors, omissions, and losses. In this respect, a coin is much stricter and more reliable; it records a fact.”

“Numismatic material sometimes literally reconstructs history, allowing entire missing periods to be restored. This was the case, for example, with Ulugh-Timur Khan, whose coins in Saraishyk and other cities made it possible to fill a gap in the chronology of the reigns of the Sarai khans in 768–770 AH. Before that, there had been a break in the sequence; the sources skipped several years. The coins showed that this interval was not empty.”

“Right now, the most interesting thing is the new finds. At the Kyshkala site, in medieval Barchyn on the territory of the Kyzylorda Region, unexpected things are being discovered — for example, silver coins with tamgas of the Chagatai Khanate, which point to closer contacts than we had assumed. We see the penetration of Chagataid and Jochid enclaves into one another, a complex map of influence that previously could not even have been imagined. Or another example: silver coins of Urus Khan in Khwarazm. This immediately forces us to look at the political situation in a new way, because the appearance of such material in such a place means a real expansion of influence and a struggle of forces that still needs to be understood more precisely.”

“Where there is a coin, we can speak almost as if we had numbers in our hands. For Southern Kazakhstan this is especially important: commodity-money relations here were developed even before the Mongols, while territories such as the Aral Sea region, Khwarazm, Crimea, and Bulgar became important centres for the spread of the Horde monetary system. On the territory of modern Kazakhstan, not only local issues are connected with the Golden Horde, but also a large number of coins that actively circulated in the region: Golden Horde, Chagataid, Ilkhanid, and Chinese coins. It is through them that we can see how trade actually worked. We often imagine the route as a direct movement from Tabriz through Otrar and Taraz to China, but in practice there were few such long-distance merchants; the route remained too difficult and expensive. The main exchange took place along short interregional routes: from Taraz to Tashkent, from Sayram to Otrar, and numismatic material shows this especially clearly.”

“At that time there were no banks, but there were hoards, and they tell us about political crises. When an enemy came, people hid their money in the ground. If they did not return for it later, it means that something extraordinary happened: war, internecine conflict, epidemic, or the capture of the population. Therefore, by the concentration of hoards, one can identify difficult periods in the life of a particular centre.”

“If we are speaking about the coins of Janibek with the double-headed eagle, then we are talking about small copper coinage of the fourteenth century, of the 1340s, about a specific monetary reform in the Volga region. These coins were issued for about ten years, and then the type changed.”

KAZAKHSTAN’S ARCHAEOLOGICAL EXPEDITION IS BRINGING A HUGE NUMBER OF WRITTEN ARTIFACTS FROM ABROAD

Participants of the international symposium on the Golden Horde in Astana discuss the history of the Ulus of Jochi, the legacy of steppe civilization and Kazakhstan’s place in Eurasian history. Golden Horde, Ulus of Jochi, Astana, Nazarbayev University, Genghis Khan, Kazakhstan, History of Kazakhstan, Medieval History, Steppe Civilization, Shanger.kz

Meruert Abuseitova, Corresponding Member of the National Academy of Sciences of the Republic of Kazakhstan, Doctor of Historical Sciences, Professor, Director of the Republican Information Centre at the R. B. Suleimenov Institute of Oriental Studies (Kazakhstan).

“A great deal of material on the history of the Golden Horde is stored not in our country, but in foreign museums and archives,” says Professor Meruert Khuatovna. “For example, we worked at the Bern Historical Museum in Switzerland and saw there a huge collection of Golden Horde coins and unique elements of yurt decoration. By the placement of the khan’s seat, marked with gold threads, one can judge the political symbolism of space. We see how the khan’s yurt was organized, what the space of power looked like, and what exactly was considered a sign of status.”

“For me, ‘Tarikh-i Jahangushay’ by Ata-Malik Juvayni, ‘The History of the World Conqueror,’ is extremely important. It is a fundamental work that describes not only political, economic, and spiritual history, but also the fate of cities, including Otrar, Balasagun, Jand, and Almaliq. In them one can glimpse everyday life: how people lived, how they ran their households, what family relations were like.”

“The problem is that for a long time Kazakhstan simply did not have a sufficiently broad base of original materials on the Golden Horde. That is why we are constantly forced to travel to foreign manuscript collections. It was precisely for this purpose that a permanent archaeographic expedition was created, and thanks to state programmes we have brought back a huge number of written sources that we did not have before. They are now being worked on: translation, correction, and preparation for introduction into scholarly circulation are underway.”

“For me, a source is an original document stored in an archive or manuscript collection. Everything else is already second-hand, third-hand, sometimes even fourth-hand. Someone saw something, translated something, omitted something, misunderstood something. And many sources are written in Persian, Arabic, and old European languages. Here maximum caution is required.”

Participants of the international symposium on the Golden Horde in Astana discuss the history of the Ulus of Jochi, the legacy of steppe civilization and Kazakhstan’s place in Eurasian history. Golden Horde, Ulus of Jochi, Astana, Nazarbayev University, Genghis Khan, Kazakhstan, History of Kazakhstan, Medieval History, Steppe Civilization, Shanger.kz

In addition to historians directly studying the Jochid Ulus, the symposium was attended by guests connected with a broader range of topics related to the heritage of the steppe world. Among them were the well-known director Rashid Nugmanov and the Egyptian historian Mohammed Riyad.

A HISTORICAL DETECTIVE STORY ABOUT JOCHI FROM THE AUTHOR OF “THE NEEDLE”

Participants of the international symposium on the Golden Horde in Astana discuss the history of the Ulus of Jochi, the legacy of steppe civilization and Kazakhstan’s place in Eurasian history. Golden Horde, Ulus of Jochi, Astana, Nazarbayev University, Genghis Khan, Kazakhstan, History of Kazakhstan, Medieval History, Steppe Civilization, Shanger.kz

Rashid Nugmanov, Kazakh film director, screenwriter, film producer, and director of the film “The Needle.”

“When I came to the subject of the Golden Horde, I immediately understood that making just another popular-science film about the era would be pointless,” says Rashid Musaevich. “For my film, I chose the circumstances of Jochi’s mysterious death. There are different versions: illness, murder, the legend of Aksak Kulan, and others. I gathered historians from Kazakhstan, Russia, Ukraine, Europe, America, Mongolia, and Canada, and asked them one question: which of the versions seems most convincing to you? That is how the structure of the film emerged, as if an investigator is trying to understand what happened, but does not deliver a final verdict.”

“There is another side to the issue as well. The film ‘Batu. A Historical Detective Story’ has been ready for a long time, but the rights to it turned out to be blocked within a system that itself cannot handle distribution. And so a paradox emerges: the film exists, interest in the subject is growing, the President speaks about the need to study the history of the Golden Horde, yet the film is effectively sitting on the shelf. It seems to me that now is precisely the right moment to return this material to the public space.”

“I am now also working on a larger screenplay, already a feature film, where the theme of Jochi and Batu will be developed differently. In a dramatic text, one can allow an authorial version, dramatic conflict, character, and the hero’s inner choice. There Batu will become a character who asks himself questions and makes decisions, including those connected with revenge for his father. The story of Jochi is so powerful and rich that it easily goes beyond the limits of a single genre.”

BAIBARS’S JOURNEY FROM THE STEPPE TO THE THRONE OF EGYPT

Participants of the international symposium on the Golden Horde in Astana discuss the history of the Ulus of Jochi, the legacy of steppe civilization and Kazakhstan’s place in Eurasian history. Golden Horde, Ulus of Jochi, Astana, Nazarbayev University, Genghis Khan, Kazakhstan, History of Kazakhstan, Medieval History, Steppe Civilization, Shanger.kz

Mohammed Riyad, Professor at Aswan University in Egypt, researcher of Baibars’s history.

“Baibars came from the Qipchaq milieu of Desht-i Qipchaq,” says Professor Mohammed Riyad. “That is why the image of Baibars is perceived as that of a man of steppe origin who did not forget his roots and rose to the summit of power in another world. In Kazakhstan, he has an almost heroic status, comparable to how he is perceived in Arab countries. A monument to him has been erected in Atyrau, and literary works have been written about him. But for Egypt, Baibars is one of the founders of the Mamluk state and the saviour of the country at a moment of mortal danger.”

“Baibars’s path to power was both typical and exceptional for the thirteenth century. As a child, he was captured in the steppe, sold into slavery, and went through the Mamluk system of military training in Egypt, where boys of Turkic and Qipchaq origin were turned into a military elite. After his training, he was freed; he became a commander, then rose even higher, and eventually took the sultan’s throne himself. This is the classic path of a Mamluk: from a captured youth to a military ruler, and in his case this path was brought to the highest degree of political effectiveness.”

“I consider Baibars a genius. In seventeen years of rule, he solved three tasks at once that before him had seemed almost impossible. He stopped the Mongols, defeated the Crusaders, and made Egypt the main centre of power in the region. At Ain Jalut, the tactics of feigned retreat, ambush, and encirclement were used, a method very close to the steppe military tradition. After this victory, the myth of the Mongols’ complete invincibility collapsed. Baibars then consistently destroyed Crusader strongholds, combining sieges, tunnelling, blockade, and manoeuvre warfare. He was the first to unite heavy Mamluk cavalry, light Qipchaq cavalry, and local infantry into a truly universal army.”

“Finally, it is very important to understand him as the architect of great diplomacy. He created the barid system, a state postal and intelligence network, thanks to which messages from Cairo to Damascus arrived in four days instead of two weeks. He restored trade with India through the Red Sea, secured religious legitimacy through the controlled Abbasid caliph in Cairo, brought Mecca and Medina under control, and, most importantly, concluded an alliance with the Golden Horde of Khan Berke against the Ilkhan Hulagu. This alliance split the Mongol world into two hostile blocs and made Egypt and the Golden Horde strategic partners for almost a century.”

Participants of the international symposium on the Golden Horde in Astana discuss the history of the Ulus of Jochi, the legacy of steppe civilization and Kazakhstan’s place in Eurasian history. Golden Horde, Ulus of Jochi, Astana, Nazarbayev University, Genghis Khan, Kazakhstan, History of Kazakhstan, Medieval History, Steppe Civilization, Shanger.kz

At the Astana symposium, participants discussed dynasties, conquests, dates, the languages of sources, ways of reading steppe heritage, political continuity, archaeology, numismatics, historical memory, and Kazakhstan’s place in this great line. Following the forum, a resolution was adopted on further international cooperation in the study and popularization of the Golden Horde’s legacy, while the platform itself, as was also stated in official speeches, is intended to become regular. In other words, this is a matter of long-term work, a series of annual meetings at which the history of the Jochid Ulus will gradually be restored into a single line of shared world history, in which Kazakhstan occupies one of the important roles.

Share:

Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to comment!

Leave a comment