Shanger.kz

Are Kazakhstan Schools Being Illegally Stripped of Kundelik?

Shanger.kz
Photo report on the conflict surrounding the transfer of Kazakhstan schools from the Kundelik platform to BilimClass. Portraits of Kundelik founder Mukhtar Ilyasov and his team in the office, IT specialists at work, parents expressing dissatisfaction with the forced transition, discussions of legal and digital risks, as well as illustrations related to electronic journals and educational platforms. Kundelik.kz, Kundelik, BilimClass, electronic journal Kazakhstan, LMS platform for schools, transition of Almaty schools, digitalization of education in Kazakhstan, Ministry of Education Kazakhstan, Almaty Department of Education, public private partnership, education PPP, Mukhtar Ilyasov, Timur Turlov, Freedom Holding Corp, BilimLand, children’s personal data, parents against transition, education reform, Kundelik court case, digital school infrastructure, NIT servers, Shanger.kz

In Almaty and several regions of Kazakhstan, schools have begun transferring electronic journals from Kundelik.kz to BilimClass. At the same time, as reported by media outlets, the Ministry of Education does not recommend changing LMS platforms in the middle of the academic year. According to sources of Shanger.kz, in practice the transition was accompanied by verbal instructions and pressure on schools, while some parents and representatives of Kundelik consider the transition procedure non-transparent and legally questionable. Shanger.kz spoke with Kundelik’s founder Mukhtar Ilyasov, his team, and parents of schoolchildren to understand how they assess the situation.

Photo report on the conflict surrounding the transfer of Kazakhstan schools from the Kundelik platform to BilimClass. Portraits of Kundelik founder Mukhtar Ilyasov and his team in the office, IT specialists at work, parents expressing dissatisfaction with the forced transition, discussions of legal and digital risks, as well as illustrations related to electronic journals and educational platforms. Kundelik.kz, Kundelik, BilimClass, electronic journal Kazakhstan, LMS platform for schools, transition of Almaty schools, digitalization of education in Kazakhstan, Ministry of Education Kazakhstan, Almaty Department of Education, public private partnership, education PPP, Mukhtar Ilyasov, Timur Turlov, Freedom Holding Corp, BilimLand, children’s personal data, parents against transition, education reform, Kundelik court case, digital school infrastructure, NIT servers, Shanger.kz

- This whole transition situation in Almaty has unsettled the public, shares Mukhtar Ilyasov. It is surprising that such decisions, including switching from one platform to another, can be made in such a short time. At meetings we ask whether state authorities understand what kind of precedent they are creating. Accusations from opponents and supporters of BilimClass claiming that Kundelik allegedly belongs to Russia are absurd. This is a Kazakhstani product.

Background information: among the owners of the competing BilimClass platform, open sources mention entrepreneur Timur Turlov, founder of the financial group Freedom Holding Corp. He was born in Russia and obtained Kazakhstani citizenship in the summer of 2022. In October 2022, by decision of the National Security and Defense Council of Ukraine, Turlov and his Ukrainian subdivision Freedom Finance Ukraine were included in the list of sanctioned individuals and legal entities.

- Parents are logging into Kundelik en masse and do not see their children’s current grades and homework because schools have stopped entering this data. People assume that we transferred the information, although we did not transfer anything and believe that the transition in Almaty was carried out unlawfully.

Photo report on the conflict surrounding the transfer of Kazakhstan schools from the Kundelik platform to BilimClass. Portraits of Kundelik founder Mukhtar Ilyasov and his team in the office, IT specialists at work, parents expressing dissatisfaction with the forced transition, discussions of legal and digital risks, as well as illustrations related to electronic journals and educational platforms. Kundelik.kz, Kundelik, BilimClass, electronic journal Kazakhstan, LMS platform for schools, transition of Almaty schools, digitalization of education in Kazakhstan, Ministry of Education Kazakhstan, Almaty Department of Education, public private partnership, education PPP, Mukhtar Ilyasov, Timur Turlov, Freedom Holding Corp, BilimLand, children’s personal data, parents against transition, education reform, Kundelik court case, digital school infrastructure, NIT servers, Shanger.kz

The history of Kundelik did not begin with capturing the market but with a state request. There was a need for an education management system because the previous government platform proved ineffective. An industrial alternative capable of covering 70 to 80 percent of schools was required. There was no time to develop everything from scratch, so Mukhtar proposed using the Russian code Diary.ru with adaptation for Kazakhstan. This is common practice in IT. A vivid example is Linux, which grew out of Unix heritage, and from Linux emerged Red Hat, Ubuntu, CentOS, Debian and others. Therefore, Kazakhstani Kundelik and Russian Diary.ru are completely different products. Mukhtar also refutes the myth that Kundelik servers are located in Russia. According to him, Kundelik is one of the few platforms whose data is located exclusively under state control.

Photo report on the conflict surrounding the transfer of Kazakhstan schools from the Kundelik platform to BilimClass. Portraits of Kundelik founder Mukhtar Ilyasov and his team in the office, IT specialists at work, parents expressing dissatisfaction with the forced transition, discussions of legal and digital risks, as well as illustrations related to electronic journals and educational platforms. Kundelik.kz, Kundelik, BilimClass, electronic journal Kazakhstan, LMS platform for schools, transition of Almaty schools, digitalization of education in Kazakhstan, Ministry of Education Kazakhstan, Almaty Department of Education, public private partnership, education PPP, Mukhtar Ilyasov, Timur Turlov, Freedom Holding Corp, BilimLand, children’s personal data, parents against transition, education reform, Kundelik court case, digital school infrastructure, NIT servers, Shanger.kz

According to Mukhtar, for the first two years the project could not be monetized and survived on personal savings and loans. Over the years, about 10 million US dollars were invested in the project. The break-even point was expected in the sixth year but due to bureaucracy and the pandemic shifted to nine years. And just when the product begins to generate at least some income for the team, BilimClass interference begins.

- Essentially, there was an element of deliberate espionage, violation of competition principles and violation of the Entrepreneurial Code, Mukhtar continues. I am disappointed in state governance. If this is how a project that passed all inspections and worked for years is treated, what signal does this send to Kazakhstani entrepreneurs? Invest and then someone will come and take it away. I believe the state is obliged to follow its own laws and signed commitments. We still have not received adequate answers from the education department and are simply being ignored. At the same time, a cassation court is ongoing in Astana regarding the situation in the Almaty region where a similar transition occurred. We litigated for almost a year, proved our case, won in the first and second instances, and the region returned to Kundelik. If everything goes well, the Almaty akimat will also have to restore the situation. If not, there will be a new round of legal proceedings.

Photo report on the conflict surrounding the transfer of Kazakhstan schools from the Kundelik platform to BilimClass. Portraits of Kundelik founder Mukhtar Ilyasov and his team in the office, IT specialists at work, parents expressing dissatisfaction with the forced transition, discussions of legal and digital risks, as well as illustrations related to electronic journals and educational platforms. Kundelik.kz, Kundelik, BilimClass, electronic journal Kazakhstan, LMS platform for schools, transition of Almaty schools, digitalization of education in Kazakhstan, Ministry of Education Kazakhstan, Almaty Department of Education, public private partnership, education PPP, Mukhtar Ilyasov, Timur Turlov, Freedom Holding Corp, BilimLand, children’s personal data, parents against transition, education reform, Kundelik court case, digital school infrastructure, NIT servers, Shanger.kz

While legal disputes continue, the Kundelik team operates in standard mode.

- One of the biggest tasks we solved eight years ago was teaching teachers how to use computers, says Marat Ishanov. When you say browser on the phone and a teacher responds what is a browser please show me where to go it does not open here, we understood that explanations by phone were impossible. We had to travel and provide hands-on training. We were shocked by the amount of reporting teachers had. Strictly speaking, they had no time to teach. At present, 40 to 50 percent of teachers’ working time has been freed thanks to automation in Kundelik. I consider this our major achievement.

The company is developing a separate school nutrition section that will allow parents to see the current menu, leave feedback, vote for meal options, track what their child ate at school, record attendance, and monitor cafeteria operations. For three years the team has also cooperated with Halyk Bank under a bonus program. For good grades students received bonuses that could be used for purchases. There were cases when parents were sincerely happy because children used accumulated bonuses to buy home appliances. The bank has now changed the mechanics of the program, but the idea of motivating and rewarding students for academic achievements remains.

- What do I think about the current situation. It is depressing. There are active parents who openly say that this is unacceptable, as if they took homeless kittens and moved them somewhere unknown. When everything is done in the middle of the academic year, it is a blow to already overloaded teachers and parents.

Photo report on the conflict surrounding the transfer of Kazakhstan schools from the Kundelik platform to BilimClass. Portraits of Kundelik founder Mukhtar Ilyasov and his team in the office, IT specialists at work, parents expressing dissatisfaction with the forced transition, discussions of legal and digital risks, as well as illustrations related to electronic journals and educational platforms. Kundelik.kz, Kundelik, BilimClass, electronic journal Kazakhstan, LMS platform for schools, transition of Almaty schools, digitalization of education in Kazakhstan, Ministry of Education Kazakhstan, Almaty Department of Education, public private partnership, education PPP, Mukhtar Ilyasov, Timur Turlov, Freedom Holding Corp, BilimLand, children’s personal data, parents against transition, education reform, Kundelik court case, digital school infrastructure, NIT servers, Shanger.kz

- Due to the replacement we received numerous complaints from parents and teachers, shares Saula Igisinova, head of user support. Many asked why we are changing the platform, whether it is true that we are transitioning, who initiated this. Teachers were dissatisfied that they had to fill in a new system again and rewrite information. Parents wrote that the new platform is inconvenient, they do not know where to go to see grades, schedule and assignments. It was difficult for us to respond because we ourselves did not understand what was happening and asked everyone to wait for an official decision.

Photo report on the conflict surrounding the transfer of Kazakhstan schools from the Kundelik platform to BilimClass. Portraits of Kundelik founder Mukhtar Ilyasov and his team in the office, IT specialists at work, parents expressing dissatisfaction with the forced transition, discussions of legal and digital risks, as well as illustrations related to electronic journals and educational platforms. Kundelik.kz, Kundelik, BilimClass, electronic journal Kazakhstan, LMS platform for schools, transition of Almaty schools, digitalization of education in Kazakhstan, Ministry of Education Kazakhstan, Almaty Department of Education, public private partnership, education PPP, Mukhtar Ilyasov, Timur Turlov, Freedom Holding Corp, BilimLand, children’s personal data, parents against transition, education reform, Kundelik court case, digital school infrastructure, NIT servers, Shanger.kz

- As a parent I have known the Kundelik system long before I joined the company, says IT director Svyatoslav Puzanov. In the past, grades could be erased in paper diaries. Modern children do not have that romanticism, but data is recorded showing what, when and by whom was entered. This is especially important for report cards, final grades and academic history. In Kundelik you can use free features or connect paid services such as analytics, comparison and class ranking. My wife gladly uses this service. The load has dropped due to regions leaving, but on average each user login is recorded and reaches about one terabyte per day. The level of automation allows processing huge volumes of tasks with a minimal number of employees.

Photo report on the conflict surrounding the transfer of Kazakhstan schools from the Kundelik platform to BilimClass. Portraits of Kundelik founder Mukhtar Ilyasov and his team in the office, IT specialists at work, parents expressing dissatisfaction with the forced transition, discussions of legal and digital risks, as well as illustrations related to electronic journals and educational platforms. Kundelik.kz, Kundelik, BilimClass, electronic journal Kazakhstan, LMS platform for schools, transition of Almaty schools, digitalization of education in Kazakhstan, Ministry of Education Kazakhstan, Almaty Department of Education, public private partnership, education PPP, Mukhtar Ilyasov, Timur Turlov, Freedom Holding Corp, BilimLand, children’s personal data, parents against transition, education reform, Kundelik court case, digital school infrastructure, NIT servers, Shanger.kz

- I manage our company’s social media and build communication between the platform and users, says chief specialist Aigerim Mukhamadieva. In recent days we have received many dissatisfied messages. Here are some examples from Instagram: 

"BilimClass looks like something hastily made and crude. Inconvenient, confusing and completely raw."
"In BilimClass there are only your classes. Half the page is taken by instructions. The left menu is inconvenient."
"Return Kundelik to us. What kind of mockery is this of parents. Bilim is a terrible inconvenient application. To send homework the child needs five screenshots. Before I sent one. Grades used to be in a table on one page and now you must open each subject separately."
"BilimClass is inconvenient. To find homework you must search for it. In Kundelik you opened it and everything was visible on one page for the whole week."
"BilimClass is a very poor platform. Everything is scattered across pages and to find necessary information you have to move back and forth. Everyone was against BilimClass but no one asked us. The education department ordered and that was it." 

- Complaints continue and parents are especially vocal.

Photo report on the conflict surrounding the transfer of Kazakhstan schools from the Kundelik platform to BilimClass. Portraits of Kundelik founder Mukhtar Ilyasov and his team in the office, IT specialists at work, parents expressing dissatisfaction with the forced transition, discussions of legal and digital risks, as well as illustrations related to electronic journals and educational platforms. Kundelik.kz, Kundelik, BilimClass, electronic journal Kazakhstan, LMS platform for schools, transition of Almaty schools, digitalization of education in Kazakhstan, Ministry of Education Kazakhstan, Almaty Department of Education, public private partnership, education PPP, Mukhtar Ilyasov, Timur Turlov, Freedom Holding Corp, BilimLand, children’s personal data, parents against transition, education reform, Kundelik court case, digital school infrastructure, NIT servers, Shanger.kz

- Before the start of the third term we were simply confronted with the fact of platform change. There was no formal notice from the class teacher, says mother of boys in grades four and six Aynur Bazhibayeva. The main issue for me is the BilimClass interface. To find homework you have to dive into previous days, which makes navigation tiring, especially when you need to quickly understand what is assigned and for which day. Because of constant stress I almost stopped using the application. I believe the previous system should be restored because parents already know how to use it and it genuinely helped monitor academic performance.

Photo report on the conflict surrounding the transfer of Kazakhstan schools from the Kundelik platform to BilimClass. Portraits of Kundelik founder Mukhtar Ilyasov and his team in the office, IT specialists at work, parents expressing dissatisfaction with the forced transition, discussions of legal and digital risks, as well as illustrations related to electronic journals and educational platforms. Kundelik.kz, Kundelik, BilimClass, electronic journal Kazakhstan, LMS platform for schools, transition of Almaty schools, digitalization of education in Kazakhstan, Ministry of Education Kazakhstan, Almaty Department of Education, public private partnership, education PPP, Mukhtar Ilyasov, Timur Turlov, Freedom Holding Corp, BilimLand, children’s personal data, parents against transition, education reform, Kundelik court case, digital school infrastructure, NIT servers, Shanger.kz

- We learned about the platform change not from official sources but from a parent chat where we were simply asked to register in the new system, says father of a sixth grade student Azamat Kadirov, name changed. There were no orders, letters or announcements on the school website or in Kundelik itself. My wife completed the registration because the message in the chat was perceived as mandatory. I reviewed the terms and saw that consent for collection, processing, storage and transfer of personal data including minors’ data is granted automatically through a public offer. In essence it looks like either agree or your child drops out of the educational process without separate informed parental consent. I am not against digital platforms but categorically against forced replacement, non-transparent decisions and a formal approach to children’s personal data. The educational process should not become an experimental field and minors’ data should not become objects of default agreements. I believe Kundelik should be returned until the end of the academic year, written explanations should be provided, and real choice should be ensured for parents and schools.

Photo report on the conflict surrounding the transfer of Kazakhstan schools from the Kundelik platform to BilimClass. Portraits of Kundelik founder Mukhtar Ilyasov and his team in the office, IT specialists at work, parents expressing dissatisfaction with the forced transition, discussions of legal and digital risks, as well as illustrations related to electronic journals and educational platforms. Kundelik.kz, Kundelik, BilimClass, electronic journal Kazakhstan, LMS platform for schools, transition of Almaty schools, digitalization of education in Kazakhstan, Ministry of Education Kazakhstan, Almaty Department of Education, public private partnership, education PPP, Mukhtar Ilyasov, Timur Turlov, Freedom Holding Corp, BilimLand, children’s personal data, parents against transition, education reform, Kundelik court case, digital school infrastructure, NIT servers, Shanger.kz

- Personally I continue to use Kundelik and do not want to switch because it is convenient and familiar, says father of four Timur Bulekbayev. I signed consent for data processing at the beginning of the academic year and believe that should be sufficient. My concerns about the new system relate to possible errors and their impact on my child’s certificate, as well as the risk of losing control over report cards at a crucial moment. I do not understand why the existing system must be changed, what this gives me as a user, how it will affect tuition costs, what will happen to academic history and who is responsible. Parents have far more questions than answers.

Photo report on the conflict surrounding the transfer of Kazakhstan schools from the Kundelik platform to BilimClass. Portraits of Kundelik founder Mukhtar Ilyasov and his team in the office, IT specialists at work, parents expressing dissatisfaction with the forced transition, discussions of legal and digital risks, as well as illustrations related to electronic journals and educational platforms. Kundelik.kz, Kundelik, BilimClass, electronic journal Kazakhstan, LMS platform for schools, transition of Almaty schools, digitalization of education in Kazakhstan, Ministry of Education Kazakhstan, Almaty Department of Education, public private partnership, education PPP, Mukhtar Ilyasov, Timur Turlov, Freedom Holding Corp, BilimLand, children’s personal data, parents against transition, education reform, Kundelik court case, digital school infrastructure, NIT servers, Shanger.kz

- After I tested the new BilimClass platform I decided to launch a petition, says mother of a fourth grader Olga Z. In my view the system has extremely poorly designed UI UX. There is no way to quickly see recent grades on one screen and no overall academic overview. Some subjects appeared such as classical guitar course that are not in our schedule. There is no comparative analytics which I regularly used in Kundelik. For the first three weeks I had installation issues and had to use the web version which was even worse. Fifty people joined the petition within a day. Later it went for moderation and was rejected.

Photo report on the conflict surrounding the transfer of Kazakhstan schools from the Kundelik platform to BilimClass. Portraits of Kundelik founder Mukhtar Ilyasov and his team in the office, IT specialists at work, parents expressing dissatisfaction with the forced transition, discussions of legal and digital risks, as well as illustrations related to electronic journals and educational platforms. Kundelik.kz, Kundelik, BilimClass, electronic journal Kazakhstan, LMS platform for schools, transition of Almaty schools, digitalization of education in Kazakhstan, Ministry of Education Kazakhstan, Almaty Department of Education, public private partnership, education PPP, Mukhtar Ilyasov, Timur Turlov, Freedom Holding Corp, BilimLand, children’s personal data, parents against transition, education reform, Kundelik court case, digital school infrastructure, NIT servers, Shanger.kz

- Preparing for the third term I tried to log into Kundelik and discovered my account was blocked, says mother of a sixth grader Asel Tanibergenova. I then logged into BilimClass to check what data of my child was there and was shocked that when entering the correct IIN the system automatically pulled my child’s personal data despite the fact that I had not given consent for transfer and processing. I did not receive a clear answer about legal grounds for the transition. The school administration changed its version about who entered data from personal files during the conversation. First they mentioned young teachers then the deputy director said she did it herself. We were simply confronted with the fact four to five days before the term began without prior notice or survey. For me this is now a matter of principle. We are not sheep but citizens and legal representatives of minors whose rights were violated..

Photo report on the conflict surrounding the transfer of Kazakhstan schools from the Kundelik platform to BilimClass. Portraits of Kundelik founder Mukhtar Ilyasov and his team in the office, IT specialists at work, parents expressing dissatisfaction with the forced transition, discussions of legal and digital risks, as well as illustrations related to electronic journals and educational platforms. Kundelik.kz, Kundelik, BilimClass, electronic journal Kazakhstan, LMS platform for schools, transition of Almaty schools, digitalization of education in Kazakhstan, Ministry of Education Kazakhstan, Almaty Department of Education, public private partnership, education PPP, Mukhtar Ilyasov, Timur Turlov, Freedom Holding Corp, BilimLand, children’s personal data, parents against transition, education reform, Kundelik court case, digital school infrastructure, NIT servers, Shanger.kz

- What would I have done differently so that today’s crisis would not exist. A difficult question. Sometimes I think maybe I would never have started Kundelik. Considering how much effort and money was invested, I understand how hard it is for law-abiding entrepreneurs and civilized investors in Kazakhstan. If such cases happen, entrepreneurship development is under serious threat. The state loses and reputation suffers. As a citizen I want Kazakhstan to continue developing, concludes Mukhtar.

The opinions of experts and the individuals featured in the material represent their personal views and do not reflect the official position of the Shanger.kz editorial team.


Share:

Comments

Chingiz
12 February 2026

Турлов лезет в Казахстане во все щели. По мне, он представляет российский капитал у нас в Казахстане

Нургиса
12 February 2026

керемет

Leave a comment